AdaWorldAPI · AdaWorldAPI · Jul 21, 2026 · Jul 21, 2026 · Jul 21, 2026 · Jul 21, 2026
diff --git a/.claude/board/EPIPHANIES.md b/.claude/board/EPIPHANIES.md
@@ -1,3 +1,47 @@
+## 2026-07-21 — E-META-UNCERTAINTY-IS-MUL-1 — the cc-thinking-skills META-UNCERTAINTY cluster (reversibility, margin-of-safety, inversion, cynefin-inputs, circle-of-competence, bounded-rationality) is ALREADY the shipped MUL contract, field-for-field — MAP it, never rebuild it; only the CONTENT-reasoning skills compose rung-3 recipes, and only the mode-router + counterfactual-pricing are genuinely missing
+
+**Status:** FINDING (operator insight — *"reversibility / margin-of-safety / inversion sound directly related to MUL"* — verified against source + confirmed independently by 3 council lenses). **Confidence:** High — the mapping is a literal field correspondence, not an analogy.
+
+**The correspondence (`contract::mul::SituationInput` already carries the skills as INPUTS):** **reversibility** = `reversibility_requirement: f64` → `GateDecision {Flow=two-way/proceed, Hold=one-way/deliberate, Block=need-input}`. **margin-of-safety** = `max_acceptable_damage` + `sandbox_available` + `allostatic_load` → the gate's risk arm (buffer sized by breach cost, exactly the skill's procedure). **inversion / circle-of-competence** = `felt_competence` vs `demonstrated_competence` → `is_unskilled_overconfident()` = the Dunning-Kruger `DkPosition::MountStupid`. **cynefin** = `complexity_ratio` + `interdependency_density` → the classifier inputs. **socratic / go-meta** = `CompassDecision {StaySurface, GoMeta}`. So the meta-uncertainty skill CLUSTER is not a rung-4 macro layer to build — it is MUL, shipped. Building a "reversibility macro" would duplicate `reversibility_requirement` + `GateDecision`.
+
+**The three-tier reshape this forces (was one flat "rung-4 macros" bucket):** **Tier 0 — meta-uncertainty cluster → MUL (zero new code, MAP only).** **Tier 1 — the ONE missing connective piece: a MUL-driven mode router** (nothing chooses between #780's shipped saccade/sweep modes). **Tier 2 — content-reasoning skills → genuine rung-4 macros** composing rung-3 recipes (first-principles≈HTD+ETD+MCT, second-order≈RTE+TCA, socratic≈MCP+SSR, steel-manning≈CDI+CR, scientific-method≈ICR+SDD+MCP). **Tier 3 — true gaps with no home: counterfactual PRICING** (opportunity-cost/regret — ICR builds the world, nothing values it), fermi-estimation, lindy-effect. Same lesson as this whole session, one layer up: the recipes already existed (wire, don't rebuild) → the meta-uncertainty skills already exist as MUL (map, don't rebuild).
+
+**Cross-ref:** `E-THINKING-SKILLS-ARE-RUNG-4-MACROS-1` (superseded in part — its "reversibility/margin/inversion as rung-4" mappings are corrected here to MUL), `mul.rs::{SituationInput, DkPosition, GateDecision, CompassDecision}`, `E-THINKING-EXPANSION-QUEUE-1` (below — the ranked build queue), `persona-vs-rung-ladder.md`.
+
+## 2026-07-21 — E-THINKING-EXPANSION-QUEUE-1 — the thinking-expansion council (5 lenses, 18 grounded candidates, all with file:line + a real-substrate probe + falsifier + iron-rule clearance) ranks the substrate's expansion surface: the mode-router is the convergent headline (3 lenses), counterfactual-pricing the one genuine new capability; everything else is substrate-grounding or the teaching loop
+
+**Status:** QUEUE (council synthesis; each entry is a registered CANDIDATE, none built — operator gates which land). **Confidence:** High that these are the right surface (multi-lens convergence + dead-end pruning); per-candidate confidence pending its probe. Deliverable: `wf_40686b6a-c14` transcript. **A productive disagreement is NAMED, not papered over** (adk-coordinator discipline): the *rung4-macro-smith* lens wants the full 5-domain Cynefin classifier; the *dispatch-mode-architect* lens KILLED it as ceremony, ruling its mechanical core (a NaN-groundedness pre-gate) + anytime-budget + restfail-escalate already cover Clear/Complicated/Complex/Chaotic. Resolution leans dispatch-mode-architect: build the honest mechanical core, not the ceremony.
+
+**Tier 1 — the mode router (convergent headline; 3 framings, build the mechanical core first):**
+- **E-DISORDER-GATE-1** ★ recommended first — a NaN-groundedness census pre-gate. Backed by a CODE-VERIFIED DEFECT: `select_tactic` reads NaN-surprise as the "routine" band → `materialize` spins 64 steps unrepresentatively. Fixes a real bug, not speculation. Probe: assert the defect on real code, then show the gate routes NaN-ctx to field-gathering (CrossTier rung-1) instead.
+- **E-RESTFAIL-ESCALATE-1** — saccade→sweep handoff on MEASURED saccade failure (`Trace.rested==false`), riding the shipped Plan→Planning kanban re-deliberation edge. Post-hoc, not predicted.
+- **E-ANYTIME-LADDER-1** — the executed ladder with a Jirak-shaped rung-boundary stopping rule: sweep-vs-saccade becomes a budget continuum (thinking that knows when to stop). Falsifier: KILL if real ctx shows a LATE-SPIKE (rungs 7-9/ICR carry the dominant gain — can't early-stop).
+- (Cynefin full 5-domain classifier: DEMOTED to the disagreement above; `DkPosition::MountStupid` veto on the "Clear" election is the MUL tie-in that survives regardless.)
+
+**Tier 2 — the one genuine new capability [DEFERRED 2026-07-21, operator]:**
+- **E-REGRET-PRICER-1** — counterfactual PRICING: settle the factual + the ICR counterfactual branch through the SAME ladder, price the difference `regret = ΔF·min(conf)`; regret-minimization = argmin over the ≤16 in-window cause rebindings. Fills `E-THINKING-SKILLS`'s named gap verbatim. Two-leg probe (fables gold causal links + D-CSW-1 planted stream). MANDATORY: probe over SubstrateView-projected ctxs, NOT the bare ICR kernel (which `recipe_claim_audit` measured as CONSTANT/input-independent — a kernel-path probe would be a tautology). **⏸ DEFERRED (operator, 2026-07-21):** regret/pricing is the **hallucination-cost gate** — it prices what an LLM error COSTS when the stakes are real-world business logic under AGI control (a safety mechanism at the control boundary, not a thinking nicety). **Park until real-world-business-logic control is in scope**; trigger = the stack begins driving real external systems. Until then the counterfactual world is CONSTRUCTED (ICR) but deliberately UNPRICED.
+
+**Tier 3 — substrate-grounding upgrades (make the tenants REAL, under rung 3):**
+- **E-QUORUM-FABRIC-1** — COMPUTE the Quorum(14)/Contradiction(15) loci from real cross-row window peers instead of hand-setting them (thinking as agreement topology); directly upgrades `recipe_substrate`.
+- **E-LOCI-CHAIN-ESCALATE-1** — formalize the E-L9-REAL-TEXT-1 chaining with a measured hop budget, escalating to a `temporal.rs` version-range read ONLY when the chain breaks (the 9-back kausal miss); the ±8 nibble never widens.
+- **E-CONTRADICTION-OPINION-1** — a stance = a row whose Contradiction locus stays bound across revisions (committed-contradiction persistence as first-class epistemic state; Staunen×Wisdom strictly on the stakes/temperature side).
+
+**Tier 4 — the teaching loop (self→other; the peer session's chess thrust, PCRLLM/MME anchored):**
+- **E-FROZEN-ORACLE-TEACHING-CHANNEL-1** — stockfish NNUE eval (byte-parity-pinned, non-drifting) into the Learned lane's NARS-revision write path (WitnessCorpus frozen-medoid pattern).
+- **E-GRADED-RUNG-EXAM-1** — MME-Reasoning items (already tagged inductive/deductive/abductive) FALSIFY the hand-assigned `recipe_dispatch::inference` map. This is the external falsifier for MY inference() table.
+- **E-CHAIN-PARITY-CREDIT-1** — PCRLLM chain-level validation as THE anti-reward-hack gate: revision credit per proof-carrying RecipeStep, never per endpoint (blocks the self-referential free-energy-inflation hack).
+- **E-DUAL-TEACHER-DIVERGENCE-1** — self-teaching vs other-teaching as the two writable autopoiesis lanes; jc battery as the standing divergence diagnostic.
+
+**Tier 5 — the verification spine (proof-carrying, replayable):**
+- **E-PROOF-IS-A-REGISTER-READING-1** — the thought-chain proof degenerates on a deterministic substrate to a 34-bit fired-mask + Lance-version premise pointer = the **FOURTH ClassView reading** of the #729 12-byte register (extends "one register, N readings" again); replay verifies from version bytes alone.
+- **E-VERSUCHSLEITER-DIFF-AUDIT-1** — the observer effect as a MEASURED mode-divergence diff (saccade vs sweep over the same version range = the orchestrator's causal fingerprint).
+- **E-VERIFY-BEFORE-ADVANCE-1** — kanban `advance_on_gate` consumes replay-verification as its predicate (with the HONEST pre-registered risk that on cheap scalar kernels verify may cost more than generate).
+- **E-PROOF-WITNESS-LOCUS-CANDIDATE-1** — OPERATOR-GATED candidate for reserved A9 slot 16 (correctly NOT assumed; binds only if a registered calibration threshold is met).
+
+**Pruned dead-ends the council killed (recorded so they don't resurface):** reversibility/cynefin/margin as new code (→ MUL, Tier 0); any new rung-3 recipe #35 (34-lock); storing any magnitude (regret price, oracle eval, lindy age, proof hash) in a reserved A9 locus (pointers-not-magnitudes + RESERVE-DON'T-RECLAIM); qualia gating/scaling logic (additive-stakes-only); contract-net auction (all kernels read the same ctx — no private info); a TeacherService/verify-endpoint/ProofChain struct (AGI-as-SoA + no new serialization); retuning `select_tactic` (E-LADDER-UNSHADOWS-SELECTOR-1 closed the gap by mode composition); widening the i4 nibble; VSA-bundling steps with natural ids (I-VSA-IDENTITIES Test 0).
+
+**Cross-ref:** `E-META-UNCERTAINTY-IS-MUL-1` (Tier 0), `E-LADDER-UNSHADOWS-SELECTOR-1` (the two modes the router chooses between), `E-RECIPE-SUBSTRATE-WIRING-1` (the substrate Tier 3 upgrades), `E-SELF-DIRECTED-GRAPH-1` + peer chess thrust (Tier 4), PCRLLM 2511.08392 + Causal-ML 2206.15475 + MME 2505.21327 (the anchors).
+
 ## 2026-07-21 — E-LADDER-UNSHADOWS-SELECTOR-1 — the measured 8/34 selector-reachability gap (`E-RECIPE-SELECTOR-REACHABILITY-1`, `66f5a73`) closes by MODE COMPOSITION, not selector retuning: `select_tactic` = the foveated SACCADE (one tactic per surprise cycle), `recipe_dispatch::ladder` = the systematic SWEEP (all 34 in rung order, each gated only by its own NaN checklist) — two dispatch modes, one catalogue
 
 **Status:** FINDING (this session; reconciles PR #780's `recipe_dispatch` with the canonical `docs/NARS_RECIPES_DISPATCH.md` shipped in `66f5a73`). **Confidence:** High — both sides are shipped + measured code; the reconciliation cross-ref is in `recipe_dispatch.rs`'s module doc.

diff --git a/.claude/board/LATEST_STATE.md b/.claude/board/LATEST_STATE.md
@@ -319,6 +319,7 @@ Membrane consumers can now pull BOTH halves of a render `classid` BBB-safely fro
 
 | PR | Merged | Title | What it added |
 |---|---|---|---|
+| **#780** | 2026-07-21 | Recipes audited → 3 real tenants wired (A9 24-loci CausalWitnessFacet + SPO + qualia) → rung-ordered NaN-gated causal ladder | 4 commits, merge `8a00988`. `recipe_claim_audit` proves the 34 kernels sound-on-proxy (28/34; 2 INERT CAS/ETD + 4 CONSTANT ARE/ZCF/ICR/HKF) but 0/34 read a real organ → wiring gap, not composition. New contract modules: `causal_witness` (A9 = 24 signed-i4 loci, THIRD ClassView reading of the #729 12-byte register, no stored bytes), `recipe_substrate` (SubstrateView projects SPO+witness+qualia; **qualia additive + stakes-only**, causality = KAUSAL witness edge; missing tenant → NaN), `recipe_dispatch` (rung-ordered NaN-gated ladder keyed by NARS inference; ICR #31 unshadowed; the systematic-sweep mode COMPLEMENTING `select_tactic`'s 8/34 saccade — E-LADDER-UNSHADOWS-SELECTOR-1). +18 tests → 970 green, clippy clean; 3 probes all-gates-green. Theory anchors: PCRLLM 2511.08392 (proof-carrying single-step, Pei Wang), Causal-ML survey 2206.15475 (SCM ladder), MME-Reasoning 2505.21327 + NARS-Swift flagged; cc-thinking-skills mapped as rung-4 macro catalogue (E-THINKING-SKILLS-ARE-RUNG-4-MACROS-1). D-REC-WIRE-1. |
 | **#676** | 2026-07-10 | Post-#674 doc arc: E-NOBODY-WAITS-1 + VISION.md (graded AGI canon) + ancestry census + D-MTS-1 design inputs | Doc-only, 4 commits. E-NOBODY-WAITS-1 banked (no messages, no actors; ractor = compile-time ownership only; `&mut` IS the serialization; prime invariant "nobody waits for anything or any scheduling"; the ack-gated advance is canonical for the **ticket tier only** — `kanbanstep` stays canonical for stream reasoning, and the ack (the **SLA gate**) is reserved for the OGAR ticket tier, repurposed consumer-side as the **actionhandler queue** (see E-ACK-HARD-GATE-VS-KANBANSTEP-STREAM-1 + E-ACK-SLA-GATE-ACTIONHANDLER-QUEUE-1); supervisor KanbanMsg drivers = TD-MESSAGE-RESIDUE, leave-as-is per operator). `.claude/v3/VISION.md` = the AGI-aspiring canon, every claim graded [G]/[G-on-proxies]/[RULING]/[ASPIRATION], 2-Sonnet-preflight + 2-Opus-filigree provenance, all 9 review fixes applied. MODULE-TABLE ancestry census: thinking-engine (51) + p64-bridge (1) + cognitive-shader-driver (22 src + build.rs) with gem-status column. Plan addendum: D-MTS-1 frozen comparison — AriGraph context V3-TENANT-SHAPED; arm-discovery + DeepNSM ingest legs; CAM-PQ 6×8=48-bit path codes (address side) vs 6×palette256² = 12 B = one V3 tenant (value side). coderabbit 5/5 findings fixed in `093489c`. Merge `001839e`. |
 | **#674** | 2026-07-10 | V3 W2–W6 continuation + comma quorum/awareness measured + 5+3 council + StyleFamily dedup (D-TSC-1) | 16 commits. `contract::style_family::StyleFamily` (12 orchestration families, frozen ordinals Deliberate=0..Metacognitive=11) + `ThinkingStyle::family()` (36→12 total) + `default_runbook()` — five mutually divergent hand-rolled 12-style tables replaced (E-FIVE-STYLE-TABLES-1); first live 5+3 council run (spec v1→v2→v3). D-MTS-5 comma quorum MEASURED GREEN (N_eff 11.00/12; boundary = spectral participation) + D-MTS-6 comma awareness MEASURED GREEN (k*=1: one stored truth bit/comma level ≈ aligned k=4; lattice buys ≈log₂12 effective bits; D-MTS-6b gates real CE64 shrink). `BatchWriter::ack_and_propose` first-ack-wins dedup (codex P2). 1549 tests green. Merge `cd5178e`. |
 | **#632** | 2026-07-02 | Cross-session intake: RouteBucketTyped (C6) + emission_scan + OCR codebook mirror + GraphRAG-rs inventory + operator rulings | Three sibling wishlists dispositioned; C6 merged verbatim (nexgen retires vendor diff); emission_scan = 2nd scan-family instance (pattern NAMED); OCR 0x08XX mirror of OGAR #148 (fuses arc: flip fuse + two-sided COUNT_FUSE — fuse FIRED 65v68 in the merge window, cleared by lock bump, 68==68); rulings: ownership+tripwires, R-1 naming phantom (domain:appid:classview), R-2 closed (512B row frozen, strided edges), L3 schema design killed; codex P2 x2 resolved (precedence global; collision documented). Contract 792/792. Merge `df367471`. |

diff --git a/.claude/board/PR_ARC_INVENTORY.md b/.claude/board/PR_ARC_INVENTORY.md
@@ -33,6 +33,16 @@
 > - **Docs** — knowledge files produced (immutable)
 > - **Confidence (YYYY-MM-DD):** — the ONLY mutable field
 
+## 2026-07-21 — lance-graph #780 — recipe claim-audit + 3-tenant wiring (A9 CausalWitnessFacet + SPO + qualia) → the rung-ordered NaN-gated causal ladder
+
+**Merged:** `8a00988` (operator-gated, ready-for-review flip mid-review). 4 commits.
+
+- **Added** — `contract::causal_witness` (`CausalWitnessFacet`, `Locus`, 24 signed-i4 loci = the A9/L9 reading, **third** ClassView reading of the #729 12-byte register, zero stored bytes; 8 tests + doctest); `contract::recipe_substrate` (`SubstrateView::project`, `affective_temperature`, `pair_similarity`; 4 tests); `contract::recipe_dispatch` (`RecipeInference`, `rung`, `dispatch_order`, `nan_disqualifier`, `ladder`; 6 tests); 3 gate-checked examples (`recipe_claim_audit`, `loci_recipe_relevance`, `recipe_ladder_over_substrate`). Contract 970 green, clippy clean.
+- **Locked** — **qualia is ADDITIVE + STAKES-only** (temperature, never a logical marker; gate-enforced byte-identity of logic under qualia swap); **causality is NOT a qualia** (the cause = `Locus::Kausal` witness edge); **rungs occupy zero loci** (view election carries escalation); **NaN disqualifier = the runtime `requires()` coverage gate** (a recipe never fires on an input the tenants could not ground); **two dispatch modes, one catalogue** (`select_tactic` saccade 8/34 + `ladder` sweep 34/34; mode composition, never selector retune — E-LADDER-UNSHADOWS-SELECTOR-1); the 34 stays rung-3-locked, new thinking = rung-4 macros (E-THINKING-SKILLS-ARE-RUNG-4-MACROS-1).
+- **Deferred** — `pair_similarity` → real ndarray 256×256 CAM-PQ table binding; NARS-Swift / MME-Reasoning `add_repo` + benchmark probe; the INERT fixes (CAS #8 / ETD #22 write-back) — flagged, not patched (kernel edits are their own PR); rs-graph-llm orchestration over the ladder; skill×recipe scored matrix (per-SKILL.md read).
+- **Docs** — `E-RECIPE-SUBSTRATE-WIRING-1`, `E-LADDER-UNSHADOWS-SELECTOR-1`, `E-THINKING-SKILLS-ARE-RUNG-4-MACROS-1` (EPIPHANIES); LATEST_STATE inventory ×3; STATUS_BOARD D-REC-WIRE-1; theory anchors PCRLLM 2511.08392 / Causal-ML 2206.15475 / MME-Reasoning 2505.21327.
+- **Confidence (2026-07-21):** working — all gates green at merge; audit exercises the real shipped kernels, not a reimpl.
+
 ## 2026-07-18 — x265/H.268 arc: PROBE-GPU-LUT + HEVC anchor + head-to-head + μ-hydration adjudication
 
 **Merged this session (3 PRs):**

diff --git a/.claude/board/STATUS_BOARD.md b/.claude/board/STATUS_BOARD.md
@@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ Plan: `.claude/plans/causal-rung-standing-wave-v1.md`. Consumes M20 A1 (shipped)
 
 | D-id | Title | Repo | Status | Evidence |
 |---|---|---|---|---|
-| D-REC-WIRE-1 | Recipe claim-audit (34 kernels measure on a scalar proxy, not the real organ) → wire the 3 real tenants (A9 CausalWitnessFacet 24 loci + SPO + qualia) into a rung-ordered, NaN-gated causal ladder keyed by NARS inference type | lance-graph | **In PR** (branch, this session) — 3 contract modules + 3 probes, 970 tests green, clippy clean, all example gates green | `causal_witness.rs`/`recipe_substrate.rs`/`recipe_dispatch.rs`; probes `recipe_claim_audit`/`loci_recipe_relevance`/`recipe_ladder_over_substrate`; E-RECIPE-SUBSTRATE-WIRING-1 |
+| D-REC-WIRE-1 | Recipe claim-audit (34 kernels measure on a scalar proxy, not the real organ) → wire the 3 real tenants (A9 CausalWitnessFacet 24 loci + SPO + qualia) into a rung-ordered, NaN-gated causal ladder keyed by NARS inference type | lance-graph | **Shipped** — PR #780 MERGED `8a00988` (operator-gated) — 3 contract modules + 3 probes, 970 tests green, clippy clean, all example gates green | `causal_witness.rs`/`recipe_substrate.rs`/`recipe_dispatch.rs`; probes `recipe_claim_audit`/`loci_recipe_relevance`/`recipe_ladder_over_substrate`; E-RECIPE-SUBSTRATE-WIRING-1 / E-LADDER-UNSHADOWS-SELECTOR-1 |
 | D-CSW-0 | Plan doc + O1 decision (canonical ladder masks + per-class facet election) | lance-graph | In PR #777; **O1 DECIDED (operator 2026-07-21: canonical masks)** | plan §2 |
 | D-CSW-1 | Standing-wave probe: per-rung persistence over an ordered stream separates causal from coincidental vs single-cycle + p64 3×u8 baseline; escalation cascade prunes at zero separation cost | lance-graph | **v5 SPLIT VERDICT** — CORE standing-wave claim GREEN (auc_wave .997 vs single .878, vs p64-**wave** .500 [M3], vs **reverse .000** [M2 orientation control, +.997]; cascade .997); the SEPARATE §0.5 escalation-ECONOMICS gate 3a **KILLS** (pruned .333 < .40 registered — reported not retuned; the M1 witness correction dropped it from v4's .458) → DEFERRED. v1 fixture-ceiling + v2 mean−std KILLs recorded on the way; leg 2 (real temporal.rs/Lance versions, wild corpora) OPEN. _(v3 historical: .972/.875/.375/.458 — pre M1/M2/M3 fixes.)_ | probe `deepnsm/examples/probe_dcsw1_standing_wave.rs` (v5); E-DCSW1-V5-SPLIT-VERDICT / E-CAUSAL-TISSUE-ALREADY-SHIPS-1 / E-DCSW1-LEG1-GREEN; plan §6.5 |
 | D-CSW-2 | Basin→causal-edge candidate probe: co-occupancy + rung survival vs basin-only / rung-only ablations | lance-graph | Queued (gated on D-CSW-1) | plan §5a/§6 |