AdaWorldAPI · AdaWorldAPI · Jul 21, 2026 · Jul 21, 2026
diff --git a/.claude/board/EPIPHANIES.md b/.claude/board/EPIPHANIES.md
@@ -55,6 +55,21 @@
 **Pruned dead-ends the council killed (recorded so they don't resurface):** reversibility/cynefin/margin as new code (→ MUL, Tier 0); any new rung-3 recipe #35 (34-lock); storing any magnitude (regret price, oracle eval, lindy age, proof hash) in a reserved A9 locus (pointers-not-magnitudes + RESERVE-DON'T-RECLAIM); qualia gating/scaling logic (additive-stakes-only); contract-net auction (all kernels read the same ctx — no private info); a TeacherService/verify-endpoint/ProofChain struct (AGI-as-SoA + no new serialization); retuning `select_tactic` (E-LADDER-UNSHADOWS-SELECTOR-1 closed the gap by mode composition); widening the i4 nibble; VSA-bundling steps with natural ids (I-VSA-IDENTITIES Test 0).
 
 **Cross-ref:** `E-META-UNCERTAINTY-IS-MUL-1` (Tier 0), `E-LADDER-UNSHADOWS-SELECTOR-1` (the two modes the router chooses between), `E-RECIPE-SUBSTRATE-WIRING-1` (the substrate Tier 3 upgrades), `E-SELF-DIRECTED-GRAPH-1` + peer chess thrust (Tier 4), PCRLLM 2511.08392 + Causal-ML 2206.15475 + MME 2505.21327 (the anchors).
+## 2026-07-21 — E-RECIPE-LOCI-ORGAN-GATE-1 — Door C: the recipe dispatch gate keyed to the REAL 24-loci causal-witness organ, closing #780 Axis B on the dispatch path; the Maslow rung climb CARRIES lower-rung awareness up (anti-rediscovery) and higher thinking PRUNES lower-related
+
+**Status:** FINDING (this session; `recipe_loci` module + `recipe_loci_walk` probe, additive/zero-dep, nothing existing touched). **Confidence:** High for the mechanism (shipped + 10 unit tests + 4 measured probe gates green); the A1-basin-6 composition is documented-not-wired (honest next step, not claimed).
+
+**What #780 left open (the precise gap).** #780's Axis-B audit measured that **34/34 recipe kernels read ONLY the 8-field scalar proxy — 0 read a real organ**. #780 wired the organs INTO the ctx (`SubstrateView`) but the DISPATCH gate (`recipe_dispatch::ladder` NaN-check, and the two shipped reach-doors) stayed scalar/style. This entry supplies the missing half: a dispatch gate keyed to the live `CausalWitnessFacet` 24 loci.
+
+**Door C — the organ gate (complements, does not replace, the two shipped doors).** `docs/NARS_RECIPES_DISPATCH.md` §7 already reaches 34/34 by **Door A** (style→mechanism fan, the wide door) + **Door B** (surprise selector `select_tactic`, the narrow door — MEASURED here at **7/34** distinct over a 270-ctx sweep, tightening the doc's "8"). Both gate on style/mechanism/scalar-surprise; NEITHER reads the organ. **Door C** (`recipe_loci::reachable`) reaches a recipe by GROUNDING its 24-dimension loci — the organ decides, not the style label. It does NOT raise the count above Door A's 34 (measured: fully-bound witness → 34); its contribution is making reachability CONTINGENT ON THE REAL ORGAN. Each recipe's `required_loci(id)` is a documented classification grounded in the recipe's own `recipes.rs::substrate` string (RCR/TCA/IDR/ICR read `Kausal`; MCT/HKF read S/P/O; SMAD/SPP read `Quorum`+`Contradiction`; …).
+
+**Carry (anti-exponential rediscovery, #777 "orientation for free").** The 24-loci register is READ, not consumed, across the whole rung walk, so a dimension grounded for a shallow recipe stays grounded for every deeper one (`carried_awareness`, MEASURED monotone non-decreasing 4→14 loci up the ascent). The cause is placed once at its rung and read by all higher rungs — observational causal discovery pays super-exponentially to RE-search it each step; here the apex reads the carried `Kausal`/`BasinAnchor`/`Antecedent` locus. The rung level occupies ZERO stored bytes (#778) — carried by WHICH loci are bound, named in the shipped `RungLevel` Maslow-pyramid vocabulary (`rung_level`), climbed by the shipped `RungElevator`. **The rung ORDER is itself organ-derived** (`loci_rung(id)` = `max(locus_rung(l))` over the required dimensions — a recipe is as deep as its deepest organ), so the WHOLE walk (order AND gate) is 24-based, not a static Tier+inference table: ICR #31 lands at the Counterfactual apex (rung 6) BECAUSE `Kausal`/`Contradiction` are apex dimensions, not because a table said 9 (the static `recipe_dispatch::rung` is kept only as a documented cross-check — the `loci_rung_is_organ_derived` test asserts they differ). This answers "still brute-force popcount, or 24-based?": the gate is per-specific-dimension (never a count), and now the order is too; the legacy scalar `nan_disqualifier` popcount path remains beside it, unchanged (#780).
+
+**Prune (higher thinking subsumes lower-related).** The dual of carry: a reachable recipe is dropped from active dispatch when a strictly-higher-rung reachable recipe requires a strict superset of its dimensions (`active_after_prune`, MEASURED 34 reachable → 18 active at the apex; RTE #1 `[MeaningLevel]` pruned by SSR #21 `[Contradiction,MeaningLevel]`; apex ICR #31 never pruned). Carry + prune = the Maslow economy: lower groundings ride UP, subsumed lower work drops OUT.
+
+**The shape it clarifies (witness vs awareness; CE64 vs V3).** The **witness** (`CausalWitnessFacet`) is POINTER-ONLY — 24×i4 = WHERE each dimension's filler sits (0=NaN). **Actual awareness** = witness ⊕ rung (elected ClassView, zero bytes) ⊕ the last-6 `part_of:is_a` NaN-skipped (the A1 `SpoFacet` L1 `6×(8:8)` taxonomy ancestry the witness's `BasinAnchor` only POINTS at) ⊕ truth+direction (A3+A6) ⊕ higher-prunes-lower. This IS the V3 vs **CausalEdge64** move: CE64 crams *(what × how-confidently × where-in-time)* into 64 fixed bits (the `I-LEGACY-API-FEATURE-GATED` pain); V3 DECOMPOSES that into full-width, content-blind facet readings over the 12-byte register (`6×2` = the `6×(8:8)` rails; `24×i4` = the loci) — the witness carries WHERE, A3/A6 carry WHAT/HOW, the ClassView elects the reading. Door C gates on the witness (the minimal organ); wiring the A1-basin-6 chain into the gate is the documented next composition (a sibling reading, no new storage).
+
+**Cross-ref:** `E-LADDER-UNSHADOWS-SELECTOR-1` (the two shipped modes Door C sits beside), `E-RECIPE-SELECTOR-REACHABILITY-1` (the 8/34 — measured 7 here), `E-RECIPE-SUBSTRATE-WIRING-1` (#780, the ctx-side organ wiring this completes on the dispatch side), `E-FOVEATED-AWARENESS-1` (the Maslow-pyramid RungLevel vocabulary + `docs/NARS_RECIPES_DISPATCH.md` §7), `E-H268-REPLAYABLE-TILE-1` (one register, N readings), `causal_witness.rs` / `awareness_facet.rs` / `cognitive_shader::{RungLevel,RungElevator}`. Files: `recipe_loci.rs` (module + 10 tests), `examples/recipe_loci_walk.rs` (4 measured gates).
 
 ## 2026-07-21 — E-LADDER-UNSHADOWS-SELECTOR-1 — the measured 8/34 selector-reachability gap (`E-RECIPE-SELECTOR-REACHABILITY-1`, `66f5a73`) closes by MODE COMPOSITION, not selector retuning: `select_tactic` = the foveated SACCADE (one tactic per surprise cycle), `recipe_dispatch::ladder` = the systematic SWEEP (all 34 in rung order, each gated only by its own NaN checklist) — two dispatch modes, one catalogue
 

diff --git a/.claude/board/LATEST_STATE.md b/.claude/board/LATEST_STATE.md
@@ -1,3 +1,8 @@
+## 2026-07-21 — branch `claude/review-claude-board-files-nhqgx1` — `recipe_loci` (Door C): the recipe dispatch gate keyed to the real 24-loci causal-witness organ + Maslow carry/prune (additive, zero-dep, nothing existing touched)
+
+### Current Contract Inventory — new entry
+- `lance_graph_contract::recipe_loci::{required_loci, loci_disqualifier, is_grounded, locus_rung, loci_rung, loci_dispatch_order, LociStep, loci_ladder, reachable, rung_level, carried_awareness, active_after_prune}` — **Door C, the 24-dimension organ gate** on recipe dispatch (closes #780 Axis B on the dispatch path). Each recipe declares which of the 16 named `causal_witness::Locus` dimensions it consumes (`required_loci`, grounded in `recipes.rs::substrate`); the rung-level walk (`loci_ladder`, in the **organ-derived** `loci_dispatch_order`) fires a recipe only when every required locus is BOUND (`loci_disqualifier` — per-specific-dimension, the 24-dim analog of `nan_disqualifier`, NOT a popcount). **Order is 24-based too:** `loci_rung(id) = max(locus_rung(l))` over the required dimensions — a recipe is as deep as its deepest organ (ICR #31 → Counterfactual apex because `Kausal`/`Contradiction` are apex dimensions), replacing the static `recipe_dispatch::rung` Tier table (kept as a documented cross-check). `rung_level` names it in the shipped `RungLevel` Maslow-pyramid vocabulary. `carried_awareness` = lower-rung groundings read UP the climb (monotone, anti-rediscovery, #777); `active_after_prune` = higher thinking subsumes lower-related (strict dimension-superset). Complements the two shipped reach-doors (A style-fan / B `select_tactic`) — neither read the organ. 11 tests + `examples/recipe_loci_walk.rs` (4 measured gates: selector 7/34, organ 34/34 when grounded, carry monotone, prune fires + apex survives). Zero deps.
+
 ## 2026-07-21 — branch `claude/x265-x266-plans-review-h9osnl` — recipes wired to real tenants: `causal_witness` (A9 24 loci) + `recipe_substrate` + `recipe_dispatch` (additive, zero-dep, nothing existing touched)
 
 ### Current Contract Inventory — new entry

diff --git a/.claude/board/STATUS_BOARD.md b/.claude/board/STATUS_BOARD.md
@@ -6,6 +6,7 @@ Plan: `.claude/plans/causal-rung-standing-wave-v1.md`. Consumes M20 A1 (shipped)
 |---|---|---|---|---|
 | D-DISORDER-GATE-1 | Tier-1 mode router (E-DISORDER-GATE-1): defect-backed NaN groundedness pre-gate + Cynefin mechanical-core classify→elect (saccade/sweep/field-gather/stabilize) + MUL MountStupid veto | lance-graph | **In PR** (branch) — `dispatch_mode` module + `disorder_gate_probe`, 982 tests green, clippy clean, 5 probe gates green | `dispatch_mode.rs`; probe `disorder_gate_probe`; E-DISORDER-GATE-1 |
 | D-REC-WIRE-1 | Recipe claim-audit (34 kernels measure on a scalar proxy, not the real organ) → wire the 3 real tenants (A9 CausalWitnessFacet 24 loci + SPO + qualia) into a rung-ordered, NaN-gated causal ladder keyed by NARS inference type | lance-graph | **Shipped** — PR #780 MERGED `8a00988` (operator-gated) — 3 contract modules + 3 probes, 970 tests green, clippy clean, all example gates green | `causal_witness.rs`/`recipe_substrate.rs`/`recipe_dispatch.rs`; probes `recipe_claim_audit`/`loci_recipe_relevance`/`recipe_ladder_over_substrate`; E-RECIPE-SUBSTRATE-WIRING-1 / E-LADDER-UNSHADOWS-SELECTOR-1 |
+| D-REC-LOCI-1 | Door C — recipe dispatch gated on the real 24-loci causal-witness organ (closes #780 Axis B on the dispatch path); rung ORDER organ-derived (`loci_rung` = deepest required dimension); Maslow climb CARRIES lower-rung awareness up (anti-rediscovery) + higher thinking PRUNES lower-related | lance-graph | **In PR** (branch, this session) — `recipe_loci` module (11 tests) + `recipe_loci_walk` probe (4 measured gates: selector 7/34, organ 34/34 grounded, carry monotone, prune fires + apex survives), clippy clean | `recipe_loci.rs`; `examples/recipe_loci_walk.rs`; E-RECIPE-LOCI-ORGAN-GATE-1 |
 | D-CSW-0 | Plan doc + O1 decision (canonical ladder masks + per-class facet election) | lance-graph | In PR #777; **O1 DECIDED (operator 2026-07-21: canonical masks)** | plan §2 |
 | D-CSW-1 | Standing-wave probe: per-rung persistence over an ordered stream separates causal from coincidental vs single-cycle + p64 3×u8 baseline; escalation cascade prunes at zero separation cost | lance-graph | **v5 SPLIT VERDICT** — CORE standing-wave claim GREEN (auc_wave .997 vs single .878, vs p64-**wave** .500 [M3], vs **reverse .000** [M2 orientation control, +.997]; cascade .997); the SEPARATE §0.5 escalation-ECONOMICS gate 3a **KILLS** (pruned .333 < .40 registered — reported not retuned; the M1 witness correction dropped it from v4's .458) → DEFERRED. v1 fixture-ceiling + v2 mean−std KILLs recorded on the way; leg 2 (real temporal.rs/Lance versions, wild corpora) OPEN. _(v3 historical: .972/.875/.375/.458 — pre M1/M2/M3 fixes.)_ | probe `deepnsm/examples/probe_dcsw1_standing_wave.rs` (v5); E-DCSW1-V5-SPLIT-VERDICT / E-CAUSAL-TISSUE-ALREADY-SHIPS-1 / E-DCSW1-LEG1-GREEN; plan §6.5 |
 | D-CSW-2 | Basin→causal-edge candidate probe: co-occupancy + rung survival vs basin-only / rung-only ablations | lance-graph | Queued (gated on D-CSW-1) | plan §5a/§6 |