fix: continuous const/id examples; 1/x not continuous on [0,1] - #629
fix: continuous const/id examples; 1/x not continuous on [0,1]#629Chessing234 wants to merge 7 commits into
Conversation
Closes the sorry left after teorth#613 flipped the false ContinuousOn claim.
Work on |x - x₀| directly; the (fun x ↦ x) x form blocked linarith.
continuous_iff_continuousOn_univ is not in scope on this mathlib pin.
h expects a point then a membership proof; the old `h (0 ∈ …)` form failed to elaborate on CI.
x ≤ 1/2 implies 2 ≤ 1/x via one_div_le_one_div with args swapped.
|
Thanks for the careful work here — but I am going to decline this one on policy grounds rather than on its merits. This PR discharges eight
The intended home for this kind of work is a downstream fork — and per CONTRIBUTING.md that "playtesting" is genuinely wanted, including feedback on whether the helper lemmas and API provided here are enough to fill the sorries in a conceptually straightforward way. Reports of places where they are not would be very welcome as issues. Note that Two notes in case they are useful for your fork:
Your statement-correction PRs remain very welcome, and several are queued and being reviewed. |
Keep the fork tip aligned with Tao's teorth#629 note (PR declined for discharging Analysis/ exercise sorrys upstream).
|
understood — won't push Analysis/ exercise solutions upstream. kept the |
Summary
Convergesto.const/Convergesto.idand fill Examples 9.4.2–9.4.3 (constant and identity continuity).¬ ContinuousOn (fun x ↦ 1/x) (Icc 0 1), closing the sorry left after fix: ContinuousOn 1/x on [0,1] is false; split Ex. 11.3.1 labels #613 corrected the false positive claim.Test plan